caranfindel (caranfindel) wrote,
caranfindel
caranfindel

Episode poll 12.04 - 'American Nightmare'


Your thoughts on 12.04, 'American Nightmare?'

LOVED IT
21(45.7%)
Loved some, liked some
13(28.3%)
Loved some, disliked some
4(8.7%)
Loved some, hated some
1(2.2%)
Loved it right up to the point where I suddenly didn't love it at all
5(10.9%)
Liked it
1(2.2%)
Didn't really care for it
1(2.2%)
Hated it so much, I think the writer should be fed rat poison
0(0.0%)

Things I loved about this episode

Priestchesters
39(5.2%)
The way the priest was dumbfounded when Fathers Penn and DeNiro believed him
26(3.5%)
That entire conversation outside the church
30(4.0%)
Dean being a 13-year-old girl
31(4.2%)
Smart!Sam
36(4.8%)
Sam trying to talk to Dean about Mary instead of just letting him act like a jerk
36(4.8%)
Dean climbing the gate as Sam steps around it
33(4.4%)
Sweaterchesters
35(4.7%)
Do you boys know God?
39(5.2%)
Sam confronting Gail about how God doesn't care what she does
34(4.6%)
MoL emblem on Sam's phone
17(2.3%)
Dean's face when he realizes he probably shouldn't kill Beth
34(4.6%)
Sam trying to convince Magda she's not evil
37(5.0%)
Sam discussing his own powers
33(4.4%)
Sam trying to save everyone while tied to a chair
38(5.1%)
Dean understanding where Mary's coming from
28(3.8%)
Sam understanding where Magda's coming from
27(3.6%)
Magda putting her head on Sam's shoulder
34(4.6%)
Mary's text message to Dean
31(4.2%)
All the pretty
34(4.6%)
All the brotherly conversations
32(4.3%)
All the Sam/Magda and Magda/Max Miller parallels
31(4.2%)
No angel and/or demon drama
29(3.9%)
Something else which I will discuss in the comments
0(0.0%)

Things I did not love about this episode

That mom was pretty awful
15(12.9%)
I don't think priests actually carry Bibles around with them all the time
9(7.8%)
I feel guilty about my inappropriate thoughts regarding priests now
8(6.9%)
Sam pushing Dean to talk about Mary
1(0.9%)
Dean being a dick to the priest and the coroner
12(10.3%)
Dean not sharing Mary's text message with Sam
20(17.2%)
Mr. Ketch, who needs to burn in Hell
26(22.4%)
Sam attacking Gail's religious beliefs
3(2.6%)
No Mary
5(4.3%)
No Cas
4(3.4%)
No Crowena
4(3.4%)
No references to real actual pop stars from the 70s and 80s
6(5.2%)
Something else which I will discuss in the comments
3(2.6%)

Are they trying to tell us Sam still has powers?

Absolutely
4(6.6%)
Not at all
5(8.2%)
I don't know
27(44.3%)
I wish he did
21(34.4%)
I don't want his powers to come back
4(6.6%)
I need to discuss this in the comments
0(0.0%)

Was Dean actually going to kill Beth when he snuck into her office at night?

Yes, because he thought she was the culprit
19(34.5%)
Yes, because she was a Wiccan
2(3.6%)
Yes, because she thought families should be split up sometimes
4(7.3%)
Yes, but only if he found evidence pointing to her
12(21.8%)
Yes, and I'm not really sure why
9(16.4%)
No
0(0.0%)
I don't even know
7(12.7%)
Let's discuss this in the comments
2(3.6%)

Unanswered questions

Why are their coffee cups always obviously empty?
11(7.2%)
Why didn't we get to see Dean vault over that gate?
14(9.2%)
Why would Sam actually TALK on his phone when he was snooping around the farm, knowing Abraham and Elijah were outside?
22(14.5%)
Why did the victims acquire stigmata from Magda's thoughts?
18(11.8%)
Are the BMoL just going to follow the Winchesters around and 'clean up their messes?' Is that their whole evil plan?
22(14.5%)
Why bring up Sam's powers if you're not trying to hint that he still has them? Why would you do this to me?
30(19.7%)
They were really considering killing Magda?
10(6.6%)
how long will it be before they bring the priest outfits out again?
25(16.4%)
How could you miss the big question I have, and why are you forcing me to ask it in the comments?
0(0.0%)

What is the title referring to?

the American dream
13(20.0%)
American Gothic
22(33.8%)
America's Most Wanted
1(1.5%)
The SPN episode called 'Nightmare'
15(23.1%)
American Idol
0(0.0%)
'Carrie,' somehow
2(3.1%)
I don't have a clue
11(16.9%)
Something else that you are too old or culturally clueless to understand, but I'll have pity on you and tell you in the comments
1(1.5%)

Your favorite outfits in this episode

Priest
27(40.9%)
Sweater
20(30.3%)
Suit
8(12.1%)
Hunter
11(16.7%)

Things that broke my freaking heart

Dean gazing longingly at the mom and son in the church
29(7.5%)
Dean texting Mary and checking for an answer
34(8.8%)
Realizing we'd seen the last of the priest outfits for the night
21(5.5%)
Dean worrying that his mom doesn't want to be with him because she's disappointed that he's a hunter
31(8.1%)
Dean thinking this family is fantastic because they seem to love each other and want to stay together
21(5.5%)
Sam having to listen to Gail talk about 'God's plan'
27(7.0%)
Sam's complete loss of any belief that God cares about people
29(7.5%)
Magda brokenly singing in the basement
31(8.1%)
Magda flogging herself
32(8.3%)
Magda believing she's the devil
30(7.8%)
Magda putting her head on Sam's shoulder
32(8.3%)
Magda getting murdered
35(9.1%)
Basically, all things Magda
33(8.6%)
Something else your black little heart didn't care about so I will discuss it in the comments
0(0.0%)

How do we feel about this new writer?

Love
27(39.1%)
Like
9(13.0%)
Meh
1(1.4%)
Dislike
0(0.0%)
Hate
0(0.0%)
Undecided
8(11.6%)
He gave us priests and sweaters... what more is there to say?
24(34.8%)


As always, no spoilers in the comments, please!
Tags: 12.04 american nightmare, episode poll, just for fun, poll, season 12, supernatural
Subscribe

  • Fic: We can be heroes, just for one day

    Genre: Gen, angst Length: About 4000 words Rating: R for violent themes and suicidal ideation Characters: Sam Winchester, Jody Mills Synopsis:…

  • Happy Supernatural Day!

    It’s Supernatural Day, the anniversary of the day the pilot first aired. And I have been watching Psych for a week rather than beginning my…

  • Untitled coda for 10.03, “Soul Survivor”

    What, now? Yes, now. A single sentence fic inspired by this Tumblr post… Dean fixes the wall, of course he does, not the very first night but as…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 19 comments

  • Fic: We can be heroes, just for one day

    Genre: Gen, angst Length: About 4000 words Rating: R for violent themes and suicidal ideation Characters: Sam Winchester, Jody Mills Synopsis:…

  • Happy Supernatural Day!

    It’s Supernatural Day, the anniversary of the day the pilot first aired. And I have been watching Psych for a week rather than beginning my…

  • Untitled coda for 10.03, “Soul Survivor”

    What, now? Yes, now. A single sentence fic inspired by this Tumblr post… Dean fixes the wall, of course he does, not the very first night but as…