Brontide by Brightly-lit - Subtle and beautifully creepy. Brightly is like, one of the nicest people in the fandom, and doesn't really participate on LJ now, so it was such a thrill to see this was her work.
Signs of Life by wetsammywinchester - Does the impossible by making "Red Meat" even better.
Abide by withthedemonblood - I cannot describe my feelings about this fic without spoiling the fic, so I'll just strongly suggest that you read it.
2081 and Higher by kalliel - One of my favorite writers ever and now she's an artist and I'm consumed with jealousy and I want to hate her but she makes it impossible, so I'll just have to be obsessed with her instead. So should you.
As Other Birds by crowroad3 - I knew this had to be Crowroad's work as soon as I read it, thanks to her gorgeous, inimitable style. Poetry and Winchesters and witches and magic... bliss!
Rae's Diner by marietwist - Art and fic and daaaaaammmmmnnn.
What Lies Beneath by madebyme_x - Another beautiful fic that hits me right in the heart and why do the people I love keep hurting me so???
Coffeehouse ft.. Alternate Universe by indiachick - Any combination of indiachick's and themegalosaurus's brains has to be amazing, and this is.
Long Before We Fall by finchandsparrow - Someone new to LJ who I'm now stalking because I hope we get more like this!
A Hiatus by themegalosaurus - A lovely curtain fic that needs to have a new chapter every week, because I don't ever want it to stop.
And finally, Message in a Bottle by tifaching - Okay, I've already recced this once, but I had to add it to this list because I love it, and not just because it was written for me. ;-)
Thanks again to the mods for organizing this challenge!