caranfindel (caranfindel) wrote,
caranfindel
caranfindel

Episode poll 14.19: “Jack in the Box”


Your thoughts on 14.19, 'Jack in the Box?'

LOVED IT
0(0.0%)
Loved some, liked some
4(19.0%)
Loved some, disliked some
2(9.5%)
Loved some, hated some
4(19.0%)
Liked it
3(14.3%)
Liked some, hated some
1(4.8%)
It was okay
1(4.8%)
Didn't really care for it
3(14.3%)
Hated it so much, I'd rather be locked in a metal coffin forever than have to watch it again
3(14.3%)

Things I loved about this episode

Dean's eulogy for Mary
8(3.1%)
And Dean working so hard to hold it together during this eulogy
10(3.9%)
Sam's funeral shirt
8(3.1%)
Learning that not all of the AU hunters were killed by Michael
3(1.2%)
New Bobby's axe-throwing skills
4(1.5%)
Snippy post-funeral Dean
8(3.1%)
'There's only one way this ends.' 'Bobby's right, we have to find Jack and help him.'
9(3.5%)
Dean crying
15(5.8%)
Duma is in charge now
2(0.8%)
Jack and Duma on their Make The World Better Tour
3(1.2%)
'Sam and Dean will like that?' 'Words can't begin to express how Sam and Dean will feel'
11(4.2%)
Jack does bad things because he's manipulated, not because he's bad
13(5.0%)
New suits with skinny pants
11(4.2%)
Dean convincing Sam to lock Jack in the box
5(1.9%)
Sam's face during this conversation
14(5.4%)
Cas killing Duma when she threatens John and Mary's (or 'John' and Mary's) happy little afterlife
8(3.1%)
Sam and Dean's talk with Jack
10(3.9%)
Especially Sam's nervous hands and the way he reacts when jack steps closer
10(3.9%)
Especially the way Dean kept saying the accident
10(3.9%)
Especially Sam being SCARED WITLESS as he puts his hand on Jack's shoulder
10(3.9%)
Dean and Sam convincing Jack to get in the box
8(3.1%)
Especially the way Sam was so nervous and obviously hated lying to Jack
13(5.0%)
Especially the way Dean was holding his emotions in
10(3.9%)
Sam's shaky 'I don't know if I can do that'
13(5.0%)
Hallucifer
2(0.8%)
Cas telling the guys what a bad idea it was to lock Jack in the box
7(2.7%)
Jack got out of the box after all
6(2.3%)
The angst
10(3.9%)
The pretty
8(3.1%)
No demon drama
4(1.5%)
Mary Winchester is still dead
5(1.9%)
Comments!
1(0.4%)

Things that broke my heart

Dean's eulogy for Mary
7(4.1%)
And Dean working so hard to hold it together during this eulogy
8(4.7%)
Dean crying
13(7.7%)
Sam realizing that Dean means to lock Jack in the box
12(7.1%)
And counts on Sam lying to Jack to make it happen
14(8.3%)
Sam and Dean's talk with Jack
11(6.5%)
Especially Sam's nervous hands and the way he reacts when jack steps closer
11(6.5%)
Especially the way Dean kept saying the accident
8(4.7%)
Especially Sam being SCARED WITLESS as he puts his hand on Jack's shoulder
13(7.7%)
Dean and Sam convincing Jack to get in the box
11(6.5%)
Especially the way Sam was so nervous and obviously hated lying to Jack
15(8.9%)
Especially the way Dean was holding his emotions in
9(5.3%)
Jack, in the box, calling Sam and Dean
14(8.3%)
Hallucifer, i.e., Jack realizing he's been tricked
6(3.6%)
Sam's shaky 'I don't know if I can do that'
16(9.5%)
Comments!
1(0.6%)

Things that were puzzling or just plain stupid

A room full of hunters watches someone kill a 'hunter' and barely reacts
19(18.6%)
None of these nephilim experts remembered that a nephilim is more powerful than its angel parent
13(12.7%)
No one made any effort to pretend they cared about Jack's comfort in the box, thereby making sure he'd realize it was a prison and not a well-intentioned time out
13(12.7%)
Dean not recognizing the pillar of salt reference from the Bible
13(12.7%)
TFW goes to investigate another Bible-related attack, and then Sam is surprised that Cas thinks it's 'another Bible thing'
11(10.8%)
Cas suddenly figuring out that Heaven might not have Jack's best interests at heart
12(11.8%)
Jack's whiplash-inducing flip from guilty to smug
11(10.8%)
Less than a day after telling himself that he can never trust Dean and Sam again, Jack trusts them enough to climb into that box
10(9.8%)
Comments!
0(0.0%)

Favorite Jack-Sam parallel

Having Dean stick him in a metal prison
10(31.2%)
Being caged with Lucifer
7(21.9%)
When you say 'favorite' you mean 'most horrifying,' right?
15(46.9%)
Comments!
0(0.0%)

How do we feel about Dean's decision to lock Jack in the ma'lak box?

It's in character for Dean, because he considers Jack a monster, and monsters who can't be killed should be locked up
10(13.5%)
It's in character for Dean, because he wants revenge for Mary's death
10(13.5%)
It's in character for Dean, because he sees it as the only way to keep his remaining family safe
7(9.5%)
It's in character for Dean, because he blames himself for the Jack situation and has to do whatever he can, no matter how painful, to fix it
6(8.1%)
It's in character for Dean, because he is scared, and he does irrational things when he's scared
9(12.2%)
It's in character for Dean, because he is angry, and he does irrational things when he's angry
13(17.6%)
It's in character for Dean, because he's pretending Jack agreed to it just as he pretended Sam agreed to be an angel vessel
6(8.1%)
It's in character for Dean for other reasons, which I will discuss in the comments
0(0.0%)
It's out of character for Dean, because he loves Jack, and the people he loves always get a pass
2(2.7%)
It's out of character for Dean, because he considers Jack family, and he wouldn't stick a family member in a metal prison
0(0.0%)
(Um, hello, Sam in the panic room?)
7(9.5%)
It's out of character for Dean for other reasons, which I will discuss in the comments
2(2.7%)
I am conflicted
2(2.7%)

How do we feel about Sam agreeing to lock Jack in the box?

It makes sense, because he knows Jack could intentionally or unintentionally hurt others, and he'd do anything, no matter how painful, to prevent that
6(8.8%)
It makes sense, because he blames himself for the Jack situation, so he's going to follow Dean's plan, no matter how much he might disagree with it
13(19.1%)
It makes sense, because he blames himself for every bad thing that's happened this season, so he's going to let Dean make all the decisions
7(10.3%)
It makes sense, because he doesn't plan to leave Jack in the box, he's working on Plan B as soon as Dean closes the lid
8(11.8%)
It makes sense, because he's scared, and he lets Dean call the shots when he's scared
5(7.4%)
It makes sense for other reasons, which I will discuss in the comments
0(0.0%)
It makes no sense, because he gives people with no redeeming qualities whatsoever a second chance, so you know someone he loves would get a third and fourth and fifth chance
11(16.2%)
It makes no sense, because he knows what it's liked to be locked up with only your own demons, and he'd never do that to anyone else
8(11.8%)
I am conflicted
7(10.3%)
It makes no sense for other reasons, which I will discuss in the comments
1(1.5%)
I am conflicted
2(2.9%)

How do we feel about Dean saying Jack 'agreed to it' and deep down, knows being locked in a box forever is 'for the best?'

We are okay with this, because it's true
2(10.5%)
We are infuriated
15(78.9%)
We have comments
2(10.5%)

Are you surprised that Jack got out of the box?

I thought he'd stay locked in there forever
0(0.0%)
I thought he'd get out, but not so quickly
11(52.4%)
I knew that wouldn't last long
10(47.6%)
I couldn't care less
0(0.0%)
I have comments
0(0.0%)

How do you feel about the season finale?

Excited
7(20.0%)
Wary
14(40.0%)
Depressed
5(14.3%)
Resigned
5(14.3%)
Spoiled
1(2.9%)
Unspoiled
3(8.6%)
Wait, this is the finale?
0(0.0%)
Comments!
0(0.0%)


Remember, no spoilers in the comments please, and that includes episode titles and casting information. Thank you!
Tags: 14.19 jack in the box, episode poll, just for fun, poll, season 14, supernatural
Subscribe

Posts from This Journal “14.19 jack in the box” Tag

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 27 comments

Posts from This Journal “14.19 jack in the box” Tag