It's time to pick the most rewatchable episode of season 6! As always, you can pick as many episodes as you want in the first round; we'll narrow it down later. Send your friends and followers - the more votes, the more scientifically accurate it is! Please vote by midnight (your time zone) on Tuesday, September 16.
And in case you've forgotten, here are the episode descriptions:
Exile on Main St. - Sam's alive! And hunting with his dead grandfather! And Dean doesn't know! And caranfindel sits there with her mouth hanging open saying "WTF?"
Two and a Half Men - Dean's adorable with a cute shifter baby, Sam's kind of a dick, and Shifter!Sam brings us one of the hottest flavors of Sam EVER.
The Third Man - Someone has stolen the Staff of Moses, we meet Balthazar, and Sam's douchemobile is destroyed.
Weekend at Bobby's - Bobby tortures a demon, helps Rufus bury a body, yells at the boys, outwits Crowley, and finally gets to eat his cobbler.
Live Free or Twihard - Sam watches Dean get turned into a vampire, and that's just messed up.
You Can't Handle the Truth - The goddess of truth gives Dean a curse that forces others to tell him the truth, except Sam of course, because something's wrong with him.
Family Matters - Cas reveals Sam's soul is missing, the brothers find out Samuel is capturing Alphas for Crowley, and they're blackmailed into helping.
All Dogs Go to Heaven - A skinwalker poses as a family dog, and Soulless!Sam is suddenly delightful, because soul or no soul, that's funny.
Clap Your Hands If You Believe... - Alien abduction! Banging patchouli! Nipples! The fourth kind is a butt thing! Did you service Oberon, king of the faeries?
Caged Heat - Soulless Sam tricks Cas, reads Meg like a book, chews through his own wrist, and is generally kind of wonderful, and Cas learns something from the pizza man.
Appointment in Samarra - Dean makes a deal with Death to get Sam's soul back, while Sam does all he can to make sure it doesn't work.
Like a Virgin - Sam gets his soul back and the brothers go after a dragon.
Unforgiven - Turns out Soulless!Sam was a naughty boy and now the sherrif, who got turned into a giant spider, wants revenge.
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning - A haunted kidney brings mannequins to life.
The French Mistake - Dean's a painted whore, Sam married fake Ruby, and that's fake me, so this must be fake mine!
...And Then There Were None - The Khan Worm (Khaaaaaaannn!!!) kills Rufus, and Gwen and Samuel Campbell are ganked as well, but do we care about them? Not particularly.
My Heart Will Go On - Balthazar and Castiel change the past, and Bobby and Ellen are an adorable couple until Fate makes everyone change things back.
Frontierland - Dean and Sam go back in time to get phoenix ash, and it's a lot germier than expected.
Mommy Dearest - Eve and the Jefferson Starships are destroyed, and it turns out Crowley is alive - and working with Castiel.
The Man Who Would Be King - Cas reveals how he got to this point, and you know who spies, Cas? SPIES.
Let it Bleed - Turns out there's a door to Purgatory, and for some reason Dean thinks erasing Ben and Lisa's memories of him will keep them safe.
The Man Who Knew Too Much - Sam's wall has been broken and he has to defeat his other selves, and Castiel becomes God.
Which episodes of season 6 do you like to rewatch?