And here are the finalists...
Time After Time - I know everybody's super excited about Dean dressed up in his 40s attire, but honestly, I'm not really into that. I don't like his slicked-down hair. What I do love, love, love about this episode is Sam and Jody. Also, I love the fact that Sam doesn't give up on finding Dean even though the situation seems hopeless. It reinforces my belief that Sam didn't look for Dean at the end of this season because he really, literally thought there was no reason to. It's the difference between "there's no way I'll get him back" and "there's no one to get back."
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie - So much to love about this episode. My favorites are Sam playing bad cop and the Sam-Dean interaction at the end. And Sam fighting killer clowns. (Careful, your Sam girl is showing.)
The Born-Again Identity - I'm surprised my fellow Sam girls didn't push this one over the top, because lord, the way a beautifully broken Sam rescues Marin while desperately needing to be rescued himself? Plus awesome concerned Dean, the return of Castiel and Meg, and the cherry on this sundae, Hallucifer? This episode is just glorious.
The Girl With The Dungeons And Dragons Tattoo - I like this one more every time I watch it. Dean walking Charlie through a flirtation is too precious for words.
So, what's it going to be?
What's the most rewatchable episode of season 7?